Restaurants
Sugar Bakery
Welcome to

Sugar Bakery

About Sugar Bakery

Welcome to Sugar Bakery, a trusted Bakery and Cake Shop in CT 06512, known for serving satisfying meals with care and consistency. With a 4.70-star rating from 692 reviews, we’re proud to offer Restroom in a welcoming setting with Wheelchair-accessible car park, Wheelchair-accessible entrance.

★★★★★ 4.70 rating (692 reviews)
0
Star Rating
0
Guest Reviews
0
Photos
0
Independent Reviews
Sugar Bakery interior
Est. Local Favorite

A Taste of Tradition

Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.

Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.

  • Fresh Daily Specials
  • Private Dining Available
  • Catering Services
  • Takeout & Delivery

Guest Reviews

Hear from our valued guests

Veena Choudary

Veena Choudary

2 years ago

Lovely experience. :) Easy to find in East Haven- the sign is not easy to spot but GPS brings you right to the door. Plenty of street parking. The store is in a small strip plaza. It is deceptive at first. However you open the door and are transported into another world- bright, cheerful, trendy gift shop while you wait in line. The line moves very quickly. :) the service is excellent. You can buy individual, 4,6,12 packs. There are cookies and other treats too. Flavors change monthly. And are seasonal. We tried the 6 pack. Delicious. The cupcakes were all moist and not cloying. They were beautifully decorated and transported so well in the wonderful carriers. Each flavor was special and distinct. :) Definitely recommend- wonderful treat and a special experience to enjoy together with your kids. :)

Jackie

Jackie

9 months ago

Great cupcakes! The cake was moist and not too sweet and the icing was so delicious. I will be coming back for sure to try the other flavors!

Tiffany Lufkin

Tiffany Lufkin

4 years ago

These are the best cupcakes around. They have so many fun and creative flavors and the cake is always moist and delicious. The Toasted Almond and the Cannoli are our favorite staple flavors and the specials are divine as well. You can order in advance online to save time, but looking in the display case is half the fun!

Jules L

Jules L

7 months ago

I ordered a birthday cake, and was delighted by the customer service (thank you, Denise!). We were thrilled with the result-the cake was fabulous! When we picked up the cake, we were tempted by the other treats in the bakery and bought several amazing decorated cookies and a cupcake. This will be my go-to bakery! A true gem.

jess g

jess g

3 years ago

I didn’t even know they were winners of an episode of cupcake wars! It definitely shows!!!! Such great cupcakes, even the gluten free ones. Delicious and made with love and care. The bakery has a little stationery and gift store up front too.

FayM “FayMous”

FayM “FayMous”

Edited a year ago

The best cupcakes in Connecticut been a fan since they were on food network cupcake war where they were the winners🏆 cupcakes are like $3.50 each please don't go up anymore. Cupcakes stay moisten literally for days upon week. You can freeze them and take then out when ready to eat them and they still will be soft and moist. 😋 my favorites strawberry cheesecake cupcakes and oreo explosion

Morgan Connell

Morgan Connell

3 months ago

I have ordered three cakes from sugar bakery and each one has been a hit! They are always the talk of the town at every event I go to because they are so beautifully decorated. I would definitely recommend !!

Krysta Lynn

Krysta Lynn

Edited 11 months ago

I order a cake from Sugar twice a year for my son and daughters birthday. Absolutely delicious cakes and cupcakes! And they look amazing! Sugar never disappoints! Great job on making my batman cake vision come to life! It looked and tasted amazing!

Kathy D

Kathy D

a year ago

First time here in years. Cupcakes are absolutely delicious. So many choices and each one is great. Cake is tender and flavorful and each icing is rich, creamy and perfect. Not too sweet. Highly recommend.

Courtney Allison

Courtney Allison

7 months ago

We ordered cupcakes from our wedding from here and they were INCREDIBLE. The flavors were out of this world - Hostess Cupcake, Oreo explosion, 24Karat to name a few. - and they also had a good gluten free option for our GF guests. I loved the seasonal flavor options. Everything was so delicious and Brenda and her staff were a pleasure to work with. It was one of the highlights of my wedding planning and day. We got lots of compliments from guests. Thank you Sugar Bakery, can't wait to be back! Sharing a few photos from guests that don't do them justice :) and my sister's menu which we had a lot of fun with.

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about Sugar Bakery

Business Features

Highlights & Amenities

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Service options

  • Delivery
  • Drive-through
  • In-store pick-up
  • In-store shopping
  • On-site services
  • Takeaway
  • Dine-in

Amenities

  • Restroom

Planning

  • Quick visit

Payments

  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments

Parking

  • Free street parking
  • On-site parking

Visit Us

We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!

Location

424 Main St, East Haven

Reservations

+1 203-469-0815

Hours

Open Now · Wednesday 9 AM-5 PM
Tuesday 9 AM-5 PM
Wednesday 9 AM-5 PM
Thursday 9 AM-5 PM
Friday 9 AM-5 PM
Saturday 9 AM-3 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday 9 AM-3 PM
Share This Business

Make a Reservation

Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.